‘No independent counterweight’: SC split on law replacing CJI in EC panel
)
The Supreme Court (Photo: PTI)
The Supreme Court on Wednesday delivered a split verdict on whether petitions challenging the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 should be heard by a larger Bench, Bar and Bench reported.
The law is under challenge mainly because it replaced the Chief Justice of India (CJI) with a Union Cabinet Minister on the selection panel for appointing Election Commissioners.
The Union government had asked the court to refer the matter to a larger bench under Article 145(3) of the Constitution. A bench comprising Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma had reserved its order on the request on July 30.
Judges differ on larger bench
Justice Datta rejected the government’s request for a larger bench and also prima facie observed that the 2023 law did not appear to ensure an independent process for selecting Election Commissioners, LiveLaw reported.
“We heard these petitions for over 5 days, speaking in one voice would have served the voice of institutional cohesion. Unfortunately we are divided in our opinion. It is a foundational principle of the constitutional scheme that rulers are bound by law and not above it,” Justice Datta ruled.
Justice Sharma disagreed with Justice Datta’s observations. He held that the case involved a substantial question of law that should be considered by a larger bench.
With the two judges differing, the bench directed that the matter be placed before the Chief Justice of India to consider whether a Constitution Bench should be formed to decide the validity of the 2023 law.
First Published: Sep 23 2026 | 3:01 PM IST